Half-Checks, Harnesses & Head Collars: Choosing What Helps Dogs Feel Safe
- Avril Munson
- Sep 20
- 5 min read
This week I shared a photo from one of our recall sessions. Another trainer commented, “What a pity to see them all in half-check collars.” I paused, felt a little bemused, and decided not to wade in on social media. They’ll have their reasons; I have mine. And while we might not agree, I think it’s important to explain—calmly and clearly—why I sometimes choose half-checks, when I don’t, and how safety, kindness and animal welfare guide my decisions.
What a half-check actually is (and isn’t)
A half-check is a flat collar with a small tightening section that closes to a preset limit. Fitted correctly, it does not choke, in fact can't ever be tight enough to choke it has very limited movement. It behaves like a flat collar most of the time, but when a dog tries to reverse or panic-pull, it tightens just enough to prevent the collar slipping over the ears. That’s it. No yanking, no “checking.” Simply security.
Why I like half-checks
1) Safety for flight risks. Some dogs—especially new rescues, adolescents, or sensitive souls—discover they can back out of loose collars or poorly fitted harnesses. Once a dog learns that escaping is possible, they’re likely to try. A well-fitted half-check removes that option kindly, which means fewer heart-in-mouth moments at gates, car parks, and field entrances.
2) A secure dog is a calmer dog. Feeling contained helps many dogs relax. If a dog senses a weak point in the equipment (a loose harness or collar that easily slips), they often scan for it—just like they’d test a wobbly fence panel. Make it secure, and most dogs stop looking for the gap.
3) Clarity without force. Used with good handling technique, a half-check behaves like a normal flat collar. It isn’t there to correct the dog; it’s there to keep them safe while we teach skills: connection, attention, steady lead work, recall, and all the lovely manners that make life easier for both ends of the lead.
When I don’t use a half-check
Equipment must match the dog and the handler’s skill on that day.
New handlers or those still learning technique. A well-fitted Y-front harness with a front attachment is usually kinder and easier while we teach technique, body language, and good handling skills, learning to speak dog and communicate without pulling the dog around.
Big, bouncy adolescents or highly reactive dogs. If arousal is sky-high, a head collar (introduced slowly and positively) may be the fairest temporary option to keep everyone safe while we train for calm.
Medical considerations. Breeds with specific neck issues, very delicate necks, or any dog with a vet-advised restriction are better on a harness.
If the dog has negative history with collars. We rebuild feelings first. Consent and comfort matter.
A note on harnesses
Harnesses can be brilliant. They spread pressure, they’re familiar to many owners, and they give us useful attachment points. But they must fit. Too loose, and many dogs can reverse out. Too tight, and we restrict shoulder movement and create discomfort.
Quick harness fit check:
The Y-strap sits flat on the breastbone, not across the throat.
You can slide two fingers under all straps; it’s snug, not tight.
The girth strap sits behind (not on) the elbow.
The dog can lift and extend their shoulders freely when walking.
If I meet a dog who’s already learned to escape a harness, I’ll often use a safety back-up: for example, harness plus a short safety link between collar and harness. Redundancy prevents disaster.
Head collars: kind, careful, and short-term
Head collars can be a gift for strong dogs in strong moments, but they need gentle introduction. We pair them with food, brief sessions, and lots of choice, building a happy association. No jerking, no tight, endless wear. Used fairly and fitted well, they buy us the calm we need to teach better habits—and then we fade them out.
Head collar checklist:
Introduce like a muzzle training plan: tiny steps, plenty of reward.
Check for rubbing; adjust padding as needed.
Keep early sessions short and positive.
Always attach the lead to a back-up point (e.g., harness) as you begin.
Different brands fit different dogs do ask if I can point you in the right direction I will. We have a few favourites based on client feedback.
How to fit a half-check kindly
We only use half checks that have a buckle closure, this means it can be fitted exactly. We have these especially made for us as they are not commonly available
When the collar is at its tightest point, you should still be able to slip two fingers comfortably between collar and neck, even more space if needed and the collar will still be safe, do experiment.
The collar simply closes enough to stop slipping over the head.
“Isn’t a half-check a choke?” (Frequently asked)
No. A choke chain tightens without limit. A half-check closes to a set size and stops. In my toolkit, aversive tools (choke chains, prongs, jerks) have no place. My goal is a dog who understands, not a dog who surrenders.
What you’ll see in my classes
At the start of sessions—especially recall and lead-work—we check equipment fit, not to judge, but to keep everyone safe. We’ll often begin with a harness set-up, then transition to a collar once dog and handler are ready. The lead work we teach is soft, steady, and quietly consistent. No wrestling. No shouting. Lots of breathing and smiling.
To fellow trainers, with respect
I know equipment can be emotive. If you saw half-checks in my photo and felt concerned, thank you for caring. We probably share the same heart for dogs. For me, the choice is never about control; it’s about preventing escapes, reducing risk, and creating the safety that allows learning to bloom. If we start from welfare and clarity, there’s room for different routes up the same kind mountain.
For owners: how to choose today
Ask, “What keeps my dog safest right now, with my handling skills today?”
If in doubt, start with a good harness and a double-ended lead, one end on the collar the other on the harness, of I prefer a single lead and a short link to the collar.
If your dog has already slipped a collar or harness, add a safe back-up while we train.
Prioritise training over tools. Equipment keeps you safe; training changes behaviour.
Gentle takeaway
My job isn’t to win arguments on the internet. It’s to help your dog feel safe enough to learn, and understood enough to relax. Whether that’s with a harness, a half-check, or a short spell in a head collar, we’ll choose the kindest path for your dog on this day—and we’ll keep listening as they tell us how it feels.
If you’d like me to check your dog’s equipment fit or talk through options, bring what you have to your next session. We’ll make a calm, safe plan together. 🌿
Avril thedogcalmer
Comments