The Power of Play: Could Playing Before Fireworks Help a Frightened Dog?
I have spent over forty years working with dogs and I am still learning from them, and it is often the simplest things I notice that leave me with the biggest questions.
I have lived with Border Collies for most of my life, so dogs who are sensitive to noise are nothing new to me, and over the years I have often used play to lift a dog’s spirits or help them through something they find worrying. Now and again the results have been quite remarkable. One example was Basil, a Labrador belonging to a client and friend, who had become terribly frightened whenever his owner started cooking. I suggested she spend two or three minutes playing ball with him before she began preparing dinner, rather than waiting until he was already worried, and within a week she told me he was so much better I almost felt I had waved a magic wand!

Of course I hadn’t, and we can’t know for certain why Basil improved, but it did make me wonder about the link between enjoyable play and fear.
Before the fear begins
We spend a lot of time thinking about what to do once a dog is frightened, and I have become much more interested in what happens before. There is a big difference between trying to persuade a frightened dog to play and starting a game with a dog who is already happy and relaxed. A truly frightened dog will often have no interest at all in their favourite ball or a treat, and who can blame them, if I was frightened out of my wits, someone waving a bar of chocolate under my nose wouldn’t help much either!
But what if the dog was already happily busy with something they loved when the frightening thing began? Would the fear be less intense, or would they recover more quickly? We know emotions influence behaviour, and that positive experiences can help dogs cope with difficult situations, and there is research into managing firework fear, including using food and play during fireworks. What really interests me is the timing, what happens if the enjoyable experience starts before the frightening event, rather than us stepping in afterwards?

Which brings me to fireworks
Every year I hear from owners whose dogs are terrified of fireworks. Some shake, hide, pant or pace, and others are so distressed they try to escape, and it is heartbreaking for owners to watch, especially when they feel there is so little they can do.
There are well established ways of managing firework fear, such as environmental management, sound desensitisation and veterinary support, with medication where appropriate, and I am certainly not suggesting a game should replace any of these. But if you know the fireworks are likely to start at seven o’clock, what if you spent a few minutes beforehand playing a game your dog absolutely loves, could it change how they react to the first bang? It might help, it might make no difference, and for some dogs, particularly those who get very worked up during play, it could even make things worse. I think all three are worth looking at.
I have decided to find out (with your help?)
After all these years I still have more questions than answers, and this is one I would really like to look into. I am starting a small observational project called The Power of Play – Firework Fear Study, and I would love dog owners to help me.
I want to hear about your dog’s experiences with fireworks, whether or not you have ever used play. Perhaps you were already playing when the fireworks started and noticed something interesting, or you deliberately began a game beforehand and felt it helped, or your dog was just as frightened as ever, or even more so. Those experiences matter every bit as much as the others. I am interested in which games your dog enjoys, how excited they get during play, whether they were already anxious before the fireworks began, and what else you have tried.
This is not a controlled scientific experiment, and a questionnaire cannot prove that play prevents fear, but by gathering a wide range of experiences, including those where play made no difference, we may start to see patterns worth looking into more thoroughly.

Would you help me?
I have put together a questionnaire for owners to share their experiences. You don’t need to have tried anything special, and you certainly don’t need to have solved your dog’s fear. If you happen to have a video of your dog’s reaction you can share it privately too, though that is entirely optional.
Please don’t deliberately expose your dog to frightening noises, or force them to play, for the sake of this project, and if your dog is severely frightened do speak to your vet.
I don’t know what we will find. It may help some dogs, it may only work in certain situations, or we may be left with even more questions, but after forty years I still think asking the questions is one of the most interesting parts of what I do.
Avril Munson Dip.Couns
Clinical Dog Behaviourist & Counsellor
Founder of thedogcalmer
Research references
Riemer, S. (2019). Not a one-way road—Severity, progression and prevention of firework fears in dogs. PLOS ONE, 14(9), e0218150.
Riemer, S. (2020). Effectiveness of treatments for firework fears in dogs. Journal of Veterinary Behavior, 37, 61–70.
Gähwiler, S., Bremhorst, A., Tóth, K., et al. (2020). Fear expressions of dogs during New Year fireworks: a video analysis. Scientific Reports, 10, 16035.





Comments